Productivity is essentially a measure of how much we produce when we work. In the UK it is measured as gross value added (which is similar to gross domestic product) per hour – basically how much £ of things are produced, on average, for every hour someone works. Growth in productivity is typically the main figure reported on.
As an economic concept, productivity growth is important because it is linked to higher wages and improved living standards. The story of history is that we produce more with less, and this has made us richer. Important drivers of productivity growth include technological improvements, a well-educated workforce, capital investments and good transport connectivity. In pre-industrial times, to make a jumper you would have to raise a sheep, shear it by hand, spin the wool by hand, dye the wool by hand, knit the jumper by hand and then transport it to market on a horse. The number of hours of labour involved in doing all this is high. Now you can use machines to make material from cotton, make a jumper with machines and transport it on a lorry, this requires far fewer hours of labour. So the input needed to make the same economic output (a jumper) is much less. Now we can all own many more jumpers, that are cheaper and in prettier colours, than we could in medieval times.
Those of us who have to interpret and explain the economy for our living will be familiar with the concept of the UK’s ‘productivity puzzle’. This is where, for reasons no-one properly understands, British productivity has grown slower than in comparable nations since the financial crisis of 2008. Many tomes have been written about this subject, including by Arlingclose, with different theories being given: including a lack of capital investment, poor standard of education, poor public transport, high immigration of unskilled workers, an overcentralised government, and of course Brexit. Well it turns out all of this is incorrect because Britain’s productivity growth has actually not been worse than other countries, it’s just that the Office for National Statistics (ONS) has been measuring productivity incorrectly for the past 18 years (1).
What’s been happening is that the ONS has been measuring hours worked – a crucial component of the calculation – as part of the Labour Force Survey. This survey involves knocking on people’s doors or phoning them to ask them questions. The same individuals would be contacted a number of times on different occasions. One of the questions asked was how many hours had been worked in the previous week. When someone wasn’t in or didn’t answer the phone on a particular occasion, which would sometimes have been because they were on holiday, the ONS assumed that the hours they had worked that week were the same as the number of hours they had said they worked in other weeks, when they generally wouldn’t have been on holiday as they were able to answer the survey. This led to a substantial underestimate of how much holiday everyone was taking: to the point where, in a failure of common sense, the ONS were showing holiday figures below the legal statutory minimum for employees, which is in turn lower than the actual average leave entitlement for employees. This led to a substantial overestimate of how much everyone was working: ONS figures indicated 31.9 hours per week in 2024 against what is now thought to be an average of 27.5 hours (2). Thinking everyone is working much more than they actually are has led to the ONS concluding we are all much less productive than we actually are.
Productivity growth was shown as 0.5% per year between 2008 and 2024. However, when the previous methodology is corrected for this, productivity growth is revised upward to 0.9% per year (3). For available comparable figures with other countries between 2007 and 2019, the UK moves from being considered the 6th worst out of 18 high-income OECD* countries in productivity growth to 6th best. Compared to the G7 countries over the same period we go from second worst to second best (4). So the UK’s “productivity puzzle” didn’t actually exist, it’s all down to poor data collection and analysis.
There are a couple of points to make in closing. Whilst it is clearly good news we’re not doing as bad as we thought we were, this doesn’t mean we’re actually any richer or more productive, we were just measuring it wrong before. Also, productivity growth has still fallen since the financial crisis in 2008. It’s just that productivity growth in Britain hasn’t slowed quite as much as we thought it had, and it hasn’t been particularly worse than in other similar countries. It’s still the case that if the financial crisis hadn’t happened, perhaps we’d all be a bit wealthier and have better living standards.
If you require advice and guidance on economic matters please contact the Arlingclose Team at info@arlingclose.com or on 08448 808 200.
* The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. The high income OECD countries in order of productivity growth are: Australia, United States, Denmark, Spain, Switzerland, UK, Japan, Canada, Portugal, Germany, Austria, France, Sweden, Netherlands, Norway, Belgium, Italy and Finland.
(1) https://blog.ons.gov.uk/2026/09/17/measuring-labour-productivity-our-new-approach/ and https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economicoutputandproductivity/productivitymeasures/methodologies/componentapproachtomeasuringlabourproductivityuk1997to2024
(2) Figure 12a of: https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economicoutputandproductivity/productivitymeasures/methodologies/componentapproachtomeasuringlabourproductivityuk1997to2024
(3) Analysis from Figure 1 of: https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economicoutputandproductivity/productivitymeasures/methodologies/componentapproachtomeasuringlabourproductivityuk1997to2024
(4) https://www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/revision-of-labour/
Other sources relied upon for this insight are:
- ‘The Rest is Money’ podcast, episode 319 ‘How to fill the Chancellor’s hold, with Dan Neidle’
- ‘More or Less’ on 23rd September 2026: ‘Has he UK’s productivity puzzle been solved’. Available on BBC Sounds



